PaintNumbered

The Best Paint for Paint by Numbers

Updated November 10, 2026

We may earn a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. How this works.

Use acrylic. It dries fast, cleans up with water, covers printed lines in two thin coats and doesn't smell. Almost every commercial kit ships with acrylic for exactly those reasons, and if you're painting a custom pattern or refilling a kit that ran dry, acrylic is still the answer.

The real question is which acrylic. Craft bottles, student tubes and artist paint all work, but they behave differently in tiny numbered cells. Here's what actually matters and which sets fit which kind of painter.

What to look for in paint for paint by numbers

Coverage (opacity)

Paint by numbers has a problem regular painting doesn't: printed lines and numbers underneath. Light colors like yellow, pale pink and sky blue are often semitransparent, so the "14" printed under them ghosts through. Look for paint described as opaque or high pigment, and expect to do two coats on pale colors no matter what.

Consistency

Medium viscosity paint (sometimes called soft body) is the easiest to work with. It flows into the corners of small cells and levels out instead of leaving ridges. Heavy body paint is thick like toothpaste, which is great for texture and annoying for flat areas the size of a pea. You can thin heavy body paint with a drop of water, just don't overdo it or it gets streaky.

Finish

Most kit paints dry fairly matte. Craft paint is usually matte too, student tubes are often satin. Mixed finishes on one canvas can look patchy under a lamp. A coat of varnish at the end evens it all out, so this matters less than people think.

Lightfastness

If the painting is a gift or will hang near a window, lightfast paint is worth it. Cheap craft paint can fade over years. Student lines like Liquitex BASICS and Winsor & Newton Galeria list lightfastness on the packaging, craft brands mostly don't.

Bottles or tubes

Bottles are easier for big batches and squeezing straight into mixing cups. Tubes keep better and take up less room. For custom patterns where you mix a lot of shades, tubes of student grade paint give you more pigment per dab.

Craft, student or artist grade?

Acrylic comes in roughly three tiers, and the difference is mostly how much pigment is in the paint.

For most people, student grade is the right answer.

How many colors should you buy?

Fewer than you think. Seriously. If your custom pattern has 24 colors, you don't need 24 tubes. A set of 12 good colors plus an extra large white and a black will mix nearly anything. The palette sheet from the PaintNumbered tool gives each number a hex code and the nearest common color name, so you know roughly what to aim for before you open a tube.

Bigger sets (36 to 50 colors) save mixing time. That's the trade. Beginners usually prefer more premixed colors, people who like mixing need fewer.

Our picks

Liquitex BASICS Acrylic Set, 24 Tubes

The default recommendation for most people. Medium viscosity, satin finish, lightfast, and enough colors that you'll mix less. Good for custom patterns that will be framed or gifted.

View on Amazon

Winsor & Newton Galeria Acrylic, 10 x 60ml Tubes

Fewer colors but big 60ml tubes, so you won't run out of the shades you use most. Better for people comfortable mixing, or anyone painting 16x20 canvases.

View on Amazon

Shuttle Art Acrylic Paint, 36 Colors in 2oz Bottles

Lots of ready made colors in squeeze bottles, plus brushes and a palette. A good value pick for families or for someone doing several kits.

View on Amazon

Apple Barrel Vibrant Spectrum, 16 Matte Colors

Classic matte craft paint in 2oz bottles. Thin and easy to brush into small cells, good for kids and practice canvases, less ideal for heirloom pieces.

View on Amazon

FolkArt Acrylic Craft Paint Set, 24 Bottles with Brushes

A well known craft paint with a wide range and a brush pack included. Fine for kits and casual painting where lightfastness isn't a priority.

View on Amazon

GOLDEN Heavy Body Acrylics Intro Set, 6 Tubes

Artist grade paint with serious pigment load, so pale colors cover printed lines better. Thick, so thin it slightly. A nice upgrade gift for someone who's hooked.

View on Amazon

A palette that keeps paint from drying

Acrylic skins over fast in open air. Once you've mixed 20 custom colors, losing them overnight hurts. A lidded palette or small cups with lids solves it.

Round Plastic Palette With Cover

Ten wells and a snap lid. Cheap, simple, keeps mixed colors usable between sessions if you add a drop of water before closing.

View on Amazon

Paint you should skip

Refilling a kit that ran out

Kit paint pots are tiny and sometimes arrive half dry. If you run out of one number, take a cotton swab of the remaining color to a well lit spot and mix from your own set until a test dab matches once dry. Acrylic dries slightly darker, so mix a hair lighter than the wet target. Or if you used the free pattern tool for your own photo, the hex code on the palette sheet gives you an exact reference.

Make a pattern from your own photo

Free and private. Your photo never leaves your device, and the printable PDF is ready in under a minute.

Open the free generator

FAQ

Can I add water to thicken or thin kit paint?

You can add a drop or two of water to paint that's gone gummy. Don't add more than about 10 to 20 percent or the paint loses adhesion and coverage. For paint that's fully dried in the pot, it's gone, replace it.

Is craft paint good enough for paint by numbers?

For practice and kids' projects, yes. For something you plan to frame or give as a gift, student grade tubes cover better and fade less.

How do I stop printed numbers showing through?

Two thin coats instead of one thick one. On very pale colors, a thin first coat of white underneath helps too.

Do I need to varnish?

You don't have to, but a spray varnish protects the surface and evens out shiny and matte patches. See the supplies checklist for options.